"Gaming" the System: Study Looks at Standards for Small-Arms Waivers for Patients on Antidepressants
Navy Medicine World Class Care. Anytime, Anywhere
Written on November 16, 2011 at 8:30
By Tom McFadden, Naval Center Combat & Operational Stress Control Public Affairs
A Sailor plays the video game, Lethal Enforcers, during the SSRI small arms
study. While playing the game participants use a plastic light pistol to
shoot foes, and avoid shooting friends, as they appear on screen in such different
scenarios as target practice, a bank robbery or a getaway.
Can a video game influence Navy policy? Cmdr. Rob McLay and Lt. Cmdr Heather
Kurera, psychiatrists at Naval Medical Center San Diego, think so. With the
help of researcher Massoud Nikkhoy of the Naval Center for Combat and
Operational Stress Control, the study seeks to provide data to determine the
effects of Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) - commonly known
as antidepressants - on a Sailor's ability to safely use small firearms.
Current Navy policy states that no Sailor being treated with SSRIs may
carry a firearm or deploy unless granted a waiver by a psychiatrist. "A couple of
years ago, we realized we had no objective standards for when it is - or is
not -appropriate to grant such a waiver," says McLay. He conceived of the
study and then brought it to Kurera, who now serves as principal
The study plans to enroll at least 100 participants through two phases of
testing - before and after the administration of SSRIs. Each session
consists of two tests: a Palm Pilot-administered measure of reaction time,
concentration and judgment (Automated Neuropsychological Assessment Metrics,
or ANAM), and - the fun part - a video game called Lethal Enforcers, in
which participants use a plastic light pistol to shoot foes- and avoid shooting
friends-as they appear on screen in such different scenarios as target
practice, a bank robbery or a getaway.
While the SSRI study is cutting edge, the video game itself decidedly is
not. Lethal Enforcers is played on a 15-year-old Sega Genesis system. Compared to
contemporary games, Lethal Enforcers looks comically outdated. There is,
however, good reason for using the Sega Genesis instead of its modern
For one, use of an outdated game significantly decreases the likelihood that
participants would have played the game at home - eliminating learned skill
as an unwanted variable in the study. More importantly, the older technology is
actually more accurate for this particular scenario.
"The newer technology won't let you use a light gun," says McLay. "When you
use a Nintendo Wii, you're using a motion sensor, which may or may not be
lined up with where the gun goes so you can't really test the same way in
terms of 'aim-shoot' on an accurate target on the newer systems."
The Sega, if all goes as planned, will be replaced by more realistic
simulators as a part of a larger study.
"Right now, we're just trying to provide preliminary data on these issues,"
McLay says, and eventually, no simulators at all because his hypothesis
imagines that the psychiatric symptoms themselves will predict performance
in firearm use.
"The neuropsychological measures will be used as a surrogate for the actual
firearms performance," he adds. "In other words, we're not thinking that
down the road every psychiatrist will need to use simulators."
"Firearm use really boils down to reaction time, impulse control and hand
steadiness. These traditional psychiatric measures should be able to predict
your ability to shoot straight - and shoot the right people."